The Erasure of Black Arabs and Black North Africans in AI: A Critical Examination

When we examine the way AI models are trained, especially models like ChatGPT, it becomes evident that certain populations are systematically underrepresented, erased, or misrepresented. One such group is the Black Arabs and Black North Africans—whose identities and histories often get lost in the dominant narratives fed into AI training processes. This lack of representation and misrepresentation is not just an oversight; it is the continuation of a deep-rooted historical erasure, perpetuated through data, and by extension, through technology.

The question arises: How are these AI systems trained, and why does the knowledge of Black Arabs and Black North Africans often get overlooked?

The Problem: Underrepresentation in AI Training Data

To understand why Black Arabs and Black North Africans are marginalized in AI, we must first consider how these models are trained. AI models like ChatGPT are built by ingesting massive amounts of text data scraped from the internet, books, and various media outlets. This data forms the foundation of the model’s “understanding” of the world. The issue lies in the types of data that are most accessible and commonly used: text that is predominantly Western, Eurocentric, and often Arab-majority in the case of North Africa.

For too long, Black North Africans have been historically erased from the dominant narrative, whether it’s through colonial lenses that depict the region as either European or Arab, or through the lack of visibility in modern digital spaces. Black Arabs and Black North Africans, whose presence in the region is as old as the Berber people themselves, are rarely represented in the content that AI systems ingest. As a result, AI models struggle to acknowledge the diverse identities of these populations, instead framing them through a reductive lens—if they are mentioned at all.

The Historical Context: Colonial Legacies and Racial Erasure

AI systems don’t operate in a vacuum. They are reflections of the data they are trained on, and this data has been shaped by colonial histories that continue to affect how we view North Africa today. For centuries, North Africa has been viewed through the prism of Arab identity or Mediterranean culture, while Black populations—especially in regions like Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia—have been marginalized, both physically and culturally.

Colonialism deeply shaped the idea of what constitutes “North African.” Under French and other European powers, the notion that North Africa was inherently Arab or Mediterranean was pushed, reinforcing the idea that Black people in the region were anomalies. This idea continues to permeate the digital content that AI models are trained on, where the reality of Black Arabs and North Africans remains hidden or reduced to oversimplified narratives. The history of the trans-Saharan slave trade, migrations from Sub-Saharan Africa, and the intermingling of ethnic groups in North Africa is all but erased in favor of a colonial vision of a “pure” Arab or Mediterranean North Africa.

How This Erasure Manifests in AI Responses

When we feed a prompt into an AI system like ChatGPT about Black Kabyles in Algeria, the response we get can be revealing. AI often reduces the presence of Black Kabyles to a “possibility”—as if their existence were some rare, isolated incident, rather than a well-documented historical reality. In fact, the presence of Black Berbers, Black Arabs, and mixed-race North Africans is an undeniable part of the region’s history. Yet, because AI models have been trained on data that privileges the Arab and European identities, the response to a question about Black Kabyles often sounds like a concession: “It’s possible, but not common.”

This framing is deeply problematic. It subtly reinforces the idea that Blackness in North Africa is somehow an anomaly, a deviation from the norm, rather than an integral part of the region’s history and cultural makeup. The AI’s refusal to acknowledge the Blackness of North African populations as normal or established echoes the historical erasure of Black Arabs and Black North Africans from mainstream discourse. Instead of embracing the complexity of North African identity, the model reinforces outdated, colonial-era stereotypes.

Why It’s a Problem: Cultural Erasure in the Digital Age

The erasure of Black Arabs and Black North Africans in AI is not just an academic concern—it’s an ethical one. AI systems are increasingly shaping how we interact with the world, influencing everything from education and media to public policy and social discourse. When AI systems consistently overlook, oversimplify, or misrepresent entire populations, it perpetuates the marginalization of those groups in society.

For Black North Africans, the consequences are real. Social and historical erasure in AI models means that their histories are not represented accurately in the digital space. This feeds into a broader societal narrative that continues to marginalize these groups and devalues their presence in the region. In the case of North Africa, the erasure also obscures the diversity of the Arab and Berber populations, presenting a false image of cultural homogeneity that doesn’t exist in reality.

The Need for Inclusive AI: A Call to Action

To correct this imbalance, it’s crucial that AI systems be trained on more inclusive and representative datasets. This means actively seeking out data that reflects the ethnic, racial, and cultural diversity of North Africa, including historical texts, oral histories, and cultural artifacts that accurately represent Black North African populations.

Moreover, there needs to be a conscious effort to collaborate with cultural experts, historians, and representatives from marginalized communities to ensure that AI systems are reflecting the true diversity of human identities. This is not just a matter of political correctness—it is a matter of ethical responsibility. By addressing these gaps in AI training, we can help ensure that marginalized communities like Black Arabs and Black North Africans are recognized and honored in both the digital world and society at large.

Conclusion: Towards an Inclusive Future in AI

The erasure of Black Arabs and Black North Africans in AI is a symptom of a much larger issue in the development of artificial intelligence: the lack of inclusivity and representation in training data. As AI continues to shape the future of human interaction, it is essential that we address these gaps and ensure that all identities, particularly those historically marginalized, are accurately and fairly represented.

AI has the potential to be a force for good, but only if it reflects the full diversity of the world it serves. The struggle to recognize Black Arabs and Black North Africans in AI is not just about acknowledging their presence in historical or cultural contexts—it is about giving them the recognition they have long been denied. Until this erasure is addressed, the racial and cultural gaps in AI will continue to perpetuate harm, reinforcing colonial stereotypes and silencing voices that have long been marginalized.

It’s time to make AI more inclusive. It’s time to make sure that Black North Africans are seen, heard, and recognized for who they are: an essential and integral part of the history and future of North Africa.

BlackArabsInAI